These days, with digitalization becoming the norm and technology permeating every sphere of everyday life, the importance of digital signatures in facilitating and streamlining document processes. However, one question intrigues those who consider using this solution: to what extent does a printed digital signature have legal validity?
It is this dilemma that we focus on in this article, unveiling the legal and technical aspects that surround this crucial topic today.
As we delve into the intricacies of legislation and the nuances of the technology involved, we will dive into a journey to discover whether printed digital signatures can, in fact, ensure the authenticity and validity of documents in an increasingly digitized world.
The difference between digital signature and electronic signature
In the legal and technological universe, two terms often come into play to describe document authentication processes: digital signature and electronic signature. Although they appear interchangeable at first glance, there are important distinctions that differentiate them, both in terms of implementation and their legal bases.
Digital signature is a more specific and technical concept, referring to an authentication method that uses cryptography to guarantee the integrity and authenticity of a document or electronic transaction.
It requires the use of public and private cryptographic keys, where the private key is unique to the signer and used to digitally sign the document, while the public key is used to verify the authenticity of the signature.
This process is governed by specific laws, such as Provisional Measure nº 2.200-2/2001 in Brazil, which recognizes the legal validity of digital signatures in electronic documents.
On the other hand, electronic signature is a broader term, encompassing a variety of electronic authentication methods that do not necessarily involve advanced encryption.
It can range from simple typing of the name to more sophisticated methods, such as biometrics. The legal validity of electronic signatures is generally supported by jurisdiction-specific laws, such as the Uniform Electronic Transactions Act (UETA) in the United States and the Payment Services Directive (PSD2) in the European Union.
Born-digital documents
The term “born-digital document” refers to documents that are created, exist and are stored in digital format since their origin, that is, there is no physical paper version. This means that these documents are designed, signed, shared and stored exclusively in electronic format, without the need to be converted to physical media.
The importance of the concept of born-digital documents in the current context is intrinsically linked to the growing digitalization of processes in various areas, such as business, government, health, education and many others. Some key points that highlight the relevance of this type of document include the ones we highlight below.
Efficiency and agility
Native-digital documents eliminate the need for printing, manual signing and physical storage, which results in more efficient and agile processes. This reduces costs and time associated with document management on paper.
Remote access and collaboration
As born-digital documents are stored in electronic format, they can be accessed and shared remotely, facilitating collaboration between individuals and organizations regardless of geographic location.
Security and integrity
The implementation of security technologies, such as encryption and digital signatures, can guarantee the authenticity, integrity and confidentiality of born-digital documents, offering a higher level of protection compared to paper documents.
Environmental sustainability
Reducing the consumption of paper and natural resources associated with the production and management of paper documents contributes to environmental sustainability, helping to minimize the negative environmental impact.
Legal and regulatory compliance
In many jurisdictions, legislation has been updated to recognize the legal validity of born-digital documents and establish guidelines for their use in different contexts, ensuring legal and regulatory compliance.
And, after all, does a printed digital signature have legal validity?
In the context of the digital era, electronic signatures have become an indispensable tool for validating documents securely and efficiently. However, it is important to understand that the legal validity of a digitally signed document remains electronic and does not automatically extend to its printed version.
This is due to the specific technical characteristics that guarantee the authenticity of the digital signature, which are lost in the printing process.
Digital signatures are based on encryption technologies that uniquely link the signatory to the electronic document. These technologies ensure that the signature is tamper-proof and that any changes to the document are detected.
The legal validity of digital signatures is also supported by specific legislation in many jurisdictions, which recognize the use of cryptographic techniques for authenticating electronic documents.
However, when printing a digitally signed document, several technical features that guarantee the authenticity of the signature are lost. For example, the printout of the document does not include the cryptographic data that makes up the digital signature, making it impossible to verify its authenticity electronically.
The paper and ink used in printing do not offer the same levels of security and protection against forgery as the encryption technologies used in digital signatures.
This discrepancy between the electronic and printed version of a digitally signed document can have several legal and practical implications.
For example, in legal disputes, the electronic version of the document can be considered as the only valid source of evidence, since it is the only one that maintains all the technical characteristics necessary to verify the authenticity of the digital signature. Furthermore, printing digital documents can create ambiguities and difficulties in interpreting the content, especially if there are discrepancies between the electronic and printed versions.
Therefore, it is essential to understand that the legal validity of a digitally signed document is intrinsically linked to the electronic medium, and that printing these documents can compromise their authenticity and integrity.
In this sense, it is recommended to adopt practices and T that guarantee the preservation of the electronic version of digitally signed documents, in order to ensure their legal validity and protect against possible disputes and forgery.
The advantages of keeping documents in digital format
Keeping documents in digital format offers a series of significant advantages that go beyond mere technological convenience. The transition to the digital world follows the evolution of modern society, bringing tangible benefits in terms of agility, sustainability, economy and organization.
Firstly, agility is one of the main advantages of keeping documents in digital format. With just a few clicks, you can access, share and modify documents instantly, eliminating the need to wait for physical deliveries or time-consuming manual processes. This speeds up workflows and enables a faster response to everyday demands.
Additionally, maintaining documents in digital format contributes to environmental sustainability. Reducing dependence on paper means reducing the consumption of natural resources, such as trees and water, and minimizing the negative environmental impact associated with the production and disposal of paper.
This approach aligns with global efforts to promote more sustainable and eco-conscious practices.
Another significant advantage is the savings provided by digital document management. Eliminating the need for paper, printing and physical storage reduces operational costs associated with maintaining physical files, such as purchasing paper, ink, printers and storage space.
The time saved through more efficient and automated processes can also result in significant savings in the long term.
Finally, organization is made easier when documents are kept in digital format. organization tools and document management allow you to categorize, search and retrieve information quickly and efficiently, ensuring the right documents are always at your fingertips when needed.
This reduces clutter and chaos associated with physical files and promotes greater productivity and effectiveness in the workplace.
The disadvantages of printing documents with a printed digital signature
Printing digitally signed documents, although it may seem like a practical solution in some cases, presents a series of disadvantages and limitations that can compromise the integrity and validity of these documents. One of the main disadvantages is the loss of legal validity of the digital signature when the document is printed.
The digital signature is supported by advanced encryption technologies and specific legislation that guarantee its authenticity and legal validity in the electronic medium.
However, when printing a digitally signed document, the technical characteristics that guarantee this validity are lost, making the signature digitally verifiable only in the electronic version of the document.
Furthermore, there are other significant disadvantages associated with printing digitally signed documents, below we list the main ones.
Loss of security
Printed paper does not offer the same level of security against forgery as a digital signature, making the document more susceptible to fraud and tampering.
additional costs
Printing documents requires additional spending on paper, ink and printer maintenance, which can increase operating costs.
Difficulty in management and organization
Printed documents can be more difficult to organize and manage, especially in large volumes, making searching and retrieving information more time-consuming and less efficient.
Environmental impact
Printing documents contributes to the unnecessary consumption of natural resources, such as trees and water, in addition to generating waste paper and ink that harm the environment.
To find out more about the topic and how to guarantee the legal validity of digital signatures, we invite the reader to download our ebook on the subject for free.
Click here to download and get detailed information and practical guidance for handling electronic documents securely and effectively.
